Sample review
Harbor Lane Family Medicine
Claim-to-source map, first check
Dr. Maya Ortiz, MD, is a family physician at Harbor Lane.
Provider · NPI 1234567893
Identity matched to NPI Registry recordDr. Ortiz is board certified in family medicine.
Provider bio claim
Not checkable from NPI · reviewer confirmsIn the cited study, 62% of children improved on a fiber plan [S1].
S1 · figure 62% found in the source excerpt
In PubMed · no retraction, correction or concern linked (checked Oct 28, 2026)Early research linked bowel symptoms to developmental disorders in children [S2].
S2 · PMID 9500320
Retracted9 in 10 families get a same-week visit.
No source cited
Figure with no source
Sources and their PubMed status
- S1
Sample source: a pediatric nutrition study
Sample source with no PMID. In a live review this row shows the article's PMID, journal and year.
In PubMed · no retraction, correction or concern linked (checked Oct 28, 2026) - S2
Ileal-lymphoid-nodular hyperplasia, non-specific colitis, and pervasive developmental disorder in children
PMID 9500320. The Lancet, 1998. Retraction notices linked: PMID 15016483 and PMID 20137807. Expression of concern linked: PMID 21971344.
Retracted (checked Oct 28, 2026) - S3
Sample source: a current clinical review (replacement for S2)
Sample source with no PMID, added to replace S2 and re-checked.
In PubMed · no retraction, correction or concern linked (checked Oct 28, 2026)
Exception queue
Three cards for the reviewer. The provider record, S1 and its figure passed quietly.
PMID 9500320
ResolvedReplaced with S3 and re-checked. The sentence now cites S3.
Dr. Maya Ortiz, MD (NPI 1234567893)
Kept with a reasonReason recorded: "Confirmed on the certifying board's public lookup."
"9 in 10 families get a same-week visit."
Kept with a reasonReason recorded: "The practice's own Q3 scheduling report."
Sign-off and export
- Attestation
- Reviewed by Dr. Dana Reyes, MD, clinical editor, as recorded by the workspace owner.
- Locked to
- sha256 4be1c0…9d27a3
- Export
- gut-health-questions.md · Sources (S1, S3) · Evidence (provider record, PubMed checks, two kept exceptions)
Sample review · CMS example NPI 1234567893 · Sample sources S1/S3 · PubMed record PMID 9500320.